The effectiveness of Polyaluminum Chloride (PAC) and aluminum sulfate (Alum) in water treatment depends on the specific application, water quality, and treatment objectives. Here's a general comparison:
1. Aluminum Sulfate (Alum) :
- It is a traditional coagulant that has been used for decades in water and wastewater treatment.
- Alum works by hydrolyzing to form aluminum hydroxide precipitates which neutralize negative charges on suspended particles and colloids, promoting aggregation and sedimentation.
- Its efficiency can be influenced by pH, temperature, and turbidity levels. At higher pH values, its effectiveness may decrease due to the formation of less soluble aluminum hydroxide species.
2. Polyaluminum Chloride (PAC) :
- PAC is a more modern coagulant with a higher molecular weight and a greater range of active species compared to alum.
- It typically shows better performance under a broader range of pH conditions because it contains both monomeric and polymeric aluminum species, some of which are effective even at higher pH levels.
- PAC often requires lower dosages than alum, thereby reducing sludge production and potentially lowering overall treatment costs.
- The polymeric nature of PAC can lead to larger floc formation, improving settling characteristics and thus enhancing solids removal from water.
In summary, while both chemicals serve as coagulants and have their respective advantages, PAC generally offers more versatility and may be more efficient in treating water with complex contaminants or varying water conditions. However, the choice between the two ultimately depends on the specific requirements of each treatment plant, including process design, raw water characteristics, and desired effluent quality. In many cases, PAC has demonstrated improved performance over alum but could also be more expensive upfront.
Polyaluminum chloride has a better effect than alum. The flocculent alum flowers form quickly, the particles are dense and heavy, and are easy to settle, which can shorten the settling time; The effluent has low turbidity, low chromaticity, good filtration performance, and can shorten the filtration cycle; High alumina content, low dosage, can reduce water treatment costs; Low corrosiveness, beneficial for pipeline protection; Easy to use and reduce labor intensity.
Keywords: PAC, Poly aluminum Chloride, poly aluminium chloride, Polyaluminum Chloride, PACL, Coagulant, Flocculant, Yellow PAC, Yellow polyaluminum chloride, White PAC, White polyaluminum chloride
Please simply fill out the Inquiry form, or Email us to serve you today!
